Jump to Recipe

Introduction

The Old Fashioned recipe is a classic and elegant cocktail. Its simplicity, rich flavors, and smooth finish make it a favorite among whiskey aficionados and casual drinkers alike. In this comprehensive guide, we’ll delve into the history of the Old Fashioned. You’ll learn the essential ingredients, explore variations, and provide tips for hosting an unforgettable Old Fashioned party. So, grab your favorite whiskey, a mixing glass, and join us on a journey through the timeless world of the Old Fashioned.

What Does an Old Fashioned Cocktail Taste Like?

An Old Fashioned cocktail offers a combination of flavors that is both bold and smooth, making it a timeless classic. The rich warmth of the whiskey forms the base of this iconic drink. With the whiskey’s unique notes of caramel, vanilla, and toasted oak shining through. The addition of sugar or simple syrup lends a subtle sweetness that balances the whiskey’s natural bite. The bitters provide a depth of flavor, enhancing the drink’s aromatic profile with hints of spice, herbs, and citrus. Finally, the expression of citrus peel imparts a burst of bright, zesty freshness that lifts the entire cocktail. The Old Fashioned recipe is a cocktail that invites you to savor and appreciate its elegant simplicity, leaving you wanting more every time.

The Origins of the Old Fashioned Recipe

A Glimpse into the Past

The Old Fashioned can trace its roots back to the early 19th century, when cocktails were typically a mix of spirits, sugar, water, and bitters. The name “Old Fashioned” is believed to have originated in the 1860s, as a nod to the “old-fashioned way” of making cocktails. However, the Old Fashioned, as we know it today, gained popularity in the late 19th and early 20th centuries. This happened during Prohibition when the addition of sugar and bitters helped mask the harsh flavors of bootleg whiskey.

The Pendennis Club Connection

One of the earliest known recipes for the Old Fashioned can be found in George Kappeler’s 1895 book, “Modern American Drinks.” However, the cocktail’s association with the Pendennis Club, a private social club in Louisville, Kentucky, is often credited with solidifying the Old Fashioned’s place in cocktail history. The club’s bartender, James E. Pepper, is said to have introduced the drink to the Waldorf-Astoria Hotel in New York City. This helped to spread its fame across the country.

Essential Ingredients to Make The Old Fashioned Recipe

The Base: Whiskey

The Old Fashioned is built on a foundation of whiskey, most commonly bourbon or rye. Choosing a high-quality whiskey is essential for a well-balanced and flavorful Old Fashioned. Bourbon typically has a sweeter, smoother flavor profile, while rye whiskey often adds a spicier, more robust taste. Experiment with different types of whiskey to find the one that suits your palate and creates your perfect Old Fashioned.

The Sweetness: Sugar

Sugar is a key component of the Old Fashioned. It provides a counterbalance to the whiskey’s heat and the bitterness of the bitters. Traditionally, a sugar cube is muddled with water and bitters in the glass. However, many modern recipes call for simple syrup, which mixes more easily with the whiskey and creates a smoother texture. Experiment with the amount and type of sugar to find the perfect level of sweetness for your Old Fashioned.

The Bitterness: Bitters

Bitters are essential for adding depth and complexity to the Old Fashioned. The most commonly used bitters are Angostura, which give a distinctive spicy, herbal flavor. However, there are many other types of bitters available, each offering unique flavor profiles that can transform your Old Fashioned. Experiment with different bitters to find the perfect match for your whiskey and taste preferences.

The Citrus: Citrus Peel

A citrus peel, typically orange or lemon, is used to express the essential oils over the drink. This adds a subtle citrus aroma and flavor to the Old Fashioned. After expressing the oils, the peel can be discarded or added to the drink as a garnish.

The Garnish: Maraschino Cherry (Optional)

While not essential, a maraschino cherry is a classic garnish for the Old Fashioned. This adds a touch of color and sweetness to the drink. For a more authentic and gourmet experience, consider using a high-quality, brandied or Luxardo cherry instead of the standard, artificially flavored maraschino cherry. The premium cherry will elevate the cocktail’s presentation and taste, making for a more sophisticated Old Fashioned experience.

Creating the Perfect Old Fashioned Recipe: A Step-by-Step Guide

Now that we’ve covered the essential ingredients for the perfect Old Fashioned, let’s dive into the step-by-step process for creating this classic cocktail.

Ingredients:

• 2 ounces of bourbon or rye whiskey
• 1 sugar cube or 1/2 ounce simple syrup
• 2-3 dashes of Angostura bitters
• A few drops of water (if using a sugar cube)
• Orange or lemon peel for expressing and garnish
• Maraschino cherry for garnish (optional)
• Ice cubes

Instructions:

1. If using a sugar cube, place it in the bottom of a rocks glass. Then add 2-3 dashes of Angostura bitters and a few drops of water. Muddle the sugar cube until it dissolves into a paste. If using simple syrup, simply add it to the glass with the bitters.
2. Fill the glass with ice cubes.
3. Pour the whiskey over the ice, and stir gently to combine the ingredients.
4. Express the citrus peel over the glass by holding it over the drink and giving it a good twist to release the oils. Optionally, run the peel around the rim of the glass to further enhance the citrus aroma.
5. Optionally, garnish the drink with the expressed citrus peel and a maraschino cherry.
6. Enjoy your timeless Old Fashioned!

Exploring Variations: A World of Flavors

With the classic Old Fashioned as your foundation, there are many variations to discover new and exciting flavor profiles. Below are a few popular variations that put a modern twist on the traditional Old Fashioned.

The Maple Old Fashioned Recipe

For a touch of natural sweetness and depth, try substituting the sugar cube or simple syrup with maple syrup. The maple syrup imparts a rich, earthy sweetness that pairs beautifully with the whiskey and bitters.

The Smoky Old Fashioned Recipe

For a unique and intriguing flavor, try adding a hint of smoke to your Old Fashioned. This can be achieved by using a smoky whiskey, such as a Scotch with a peaty profile, or by using a smoking gun or handheld smoker to infuse the drink with a subtle smoky aroma.

The Chocolate Old Fashioned Recipe

For a dessert-like twist on the classic Old Fashioned, incorporate chocolate bitters in place of or in addition to the Angostura bitters. The chocolate bitters add a rich, velvety flavor that complements the whiskey and adds a luxurious, indulgent touch to the drink.

The Spiced Old Fashioned Recipe

For a warm and inviting Old Fashioned, try incorporating spiced simple syrup or spiced bitters, such as cinnamon or clove bitters. These spices add a cozy, seasonal touch to the classic cocktail, making it perfect for sipping by the fire on a chilly evening.

Hosting an Old Fashioned Cocktail Party: Tips for Success

Recipe Prepping in Advance

To ensure a seamless and enjoyable Old Fashioned party, it’s essential to prepare as much as possible in advance. Here are some tips for prepping your Old Fashioned ingredients and bar area before the party begins:

1. Stock up on ingredients: Make sure you have enough whiskey, sugar, bitters, citrus peels, and garnishes to accommodate the number of guests you’re expecting. It’s always better to have more than you think you’ll need, just in case.

2. Batch your simple syrup: If you plan to use simple syrup instead of sugar cubes, make a large batch ahead of time and store it in a bottle or jar for easy pouring during the party. You can also create multiple flavors of simple syrup, such as spiced or infused with herbs, for guests to experiment with.
3. Pre-cut citrus peels: Cut your citrus peels into strips or twists ahead of time and store them in a covered container in the refrigerator. This will save time during the party and help keep your bar area clean and organized.
4. Chill your whiskey: While not necessary, chilling your whiskey before the party can help ensure a consistently cold and refreshing Old Fashioned. Simply place the bottles in the refrigerator a few hours before the event.

Setting the Scene: A Vintage-Inspired Bar Area

Creating a vintage-inspired bar area for your Old Fashioned party will transport your guests back in time and set the mood for an evening of elegant cocktails and lively conversation. Here are a few ideas to help you create the perfect Old Fashioned bar area:

1. Use vintage glassware: Serve your Old Fashioneds in vintage rocks glasses or cut crystal glasses to evoke the glamour of a bygone era.
2. Display your ingredients: Arrange your whiskey, sugar, bitters, and garnishes on a vintage tray or bar cart to create an attractive and functional focal point.
3. Include an ice bucket and tongs: A stylish ice bucket and tongs will make it easy for guests to add ice to their drinks and maintain the proper temperature for their Old Fashioneds.
4. Provide recipe cards: Provide recipe cards with the classic Old Fashioned recipe and variations for guests to follow or experiment with as they mix their drinks.
5. Add vintage decor: Incorporate vintage-inspired decor, such as antique cocktail shakers, old-fashioned bar tools, and framed vintage cocktail advertisements, to complete the look and feel of your Old Fashioned party.

Final Thoughts

The Old Fashioned Recipe is a timeless cocktail that has endured for generations, thanks to its elegant simplicity and rich, satisfying flavors. By understanding the essential ingredients, mastering the classic recipe, exploring variations, and hosting a memorable Old Fashioned party, you can share the magic of this iconic cocktail with friends and family and create cherished memories to last a lifetime. Cheers to the Old Fashioned and to those who continue to celebrate its enduring appeal!

Old Fashioned Cocktails are great, but these cocktails are worth trying next: